State Arm of National Business Association Eyes Ogdensburg Lawsuit Over $35 Million Project

From The Watertown Daily Times

OGDENSBURG — A spokesperson for the state chapter of a national construction association representing non-union companies and their workers says the organization’s board of directors will decide whether to mount a legal challenge in state Supreme Court over the City Council’s recent decision to adopt a Project Labor Agreement during its $35 million wastewater treatment plant rebuild.

“Obviously, it has been an interest of ours, this project,” said Amanda Bertram, vice president of communications for the Empire State Chapter of Associated Builders and Contractors. “Our plan going forward is to present this to our board of directors and our contractor members and, if they choose to, we will file the appropriate legal paperwork and stop the PLA,” she said.

Ms. Bertram said her organization did just that approximately two years ago when it protested a PLA agreement related to the $42 million expansion of the Plattsburgh International Airport.

“We did it in Plattsburgh,” Ms. Bertram said Friday. “Certainly we are not afraid to take legal action.”

The association Ms. Bertram speaks for represents close to 400 members throughout New York state. It has a central office in East Syracuse and branch offices in Albany, Buffalo, Rochester, Long Island and the New York City metropolitan area. Nationally, the Associated Builders and Contractors represents 22,000 members from more than 19,000 construction and industrial firms, according to Ms. Bertram.

Last year, city officials heard from Ms. Bertram and other open-shop contractors, arguing that a pre-exisiting labor agreement, known as a PLA, would scuttle the ability of non-union contractors in the region to bid on the municipal project.

Despite those objections, City Council commissioned a $21,000 study that claimed the municipality could save upwards of $900,000 by entering into a union-supporting PLA.

As a result of the study, Ogdensburg City Council then voted unanimously to utilize such an agreement. The decision was met with applause from local labor leaders and rank and file union members in attendance.

But Friday, Ms. Bertram suggested that her state and national association has not taken its eye off the ball regarding the $35 million Ogdensburg project. She said at stake is the ability for all businesses and workers to compete.

“Frankly, someone needs to be an advocate for the taxpayers of Ogdensburg and laborers on the project, whether they be union or not,” Ms. Bertram said.

When contacted Friday, Ogdensburg City Manager Sarah Purdy declined comment regarding the threat of a lawsuit. She was specifically asked how such a suit would affect the plant’s construction timeline.

Ms. Bertram said a decision on whether to sue the city will come soon.

“We are going to present this to our board of directors and our contract members. They are meeting next week,” she said. “We don’t shy away from legal action.”

Founded on the merit shop philosophy, the Associated Builders and Contractors organization and its 72 chapters help members win work and deliver that work safely, ethically and profitably for the betterment of the communities in which they work, according to the organization’s website. Membership, according to the association, represents all specialties within the U.S. construction industry and is composed primarily of firms that perform work in the industrial and commercial sectors of the industry.

In a recent letter to the editor in the Watertown Daily Times, Ms. Bertram argued that a PLA contract in Ogdensburg, despite claims, will not save money because it limits who can bid on a major project.

“While flawed PLA studies are conducted in advance of a project to identify alleged savings, nothing is ever done after to determine if the savings were realized,” Ms. Bertram wrote. “Perhaps that’s because it would prove what we’ve been saying for years: PLAs don’t actually save anything and, in fact, cost more.”

As a full-service trade association, ABC offers a variety of information, tools and services to its members.


Union Requirement Inflates Cost of State Fair Bridge

By |May 23rd, 2019|Categories: News, Statewide|

A shortage of bids on the New York State Fairgrounds pedestrian bridge project will leave New Yorkers paying more, but getting less. When plans for the project were released with an accompanying project labor agreement (PLA), the playing field narrowed from 20 companies interested in the project to just two submitting bids, with the lowest bid coming in well in excess of $1 million over engineering estimates. Why the drastic decrease in competition and increase in costs? The answer can be found in three simple letters: PLA.

Another Voice: Benefits Add Hidden Costs to Prevailing Wage Projects

By |May 22nd, 2019|Categories: Statewide, Uncategorized|

Let’s not be fooled. Proponents of the expansion of prevailing wage are already doing great damage to taxpayers. They shouldn’t be allowed to ruin what little positive job growth we now have in New York.

Trade War: Find Out How The Tariffs Are Impacting New York Businesses and Consumers

By |May 17th, 2019|Categories: Federal Update, News, Statewide|

“What’s clear is that some contractors will have to deal with cost overruns that they can’t pass on to their customers,” said Brian Sampson, president of the Associated Builders & Contractors of New York. “But in most cases, the increased cost of the tariffs will be passed on to customers resulting in more expensive construction projects or higher costs for capital goods.”

First JCC Trades Training Class Graduates; Honored by Officials

By |May 13th, 2019|Categories: News, Statewide, Uncategorized|

The first class to complete the intensive 10-week, 40-hour construction training course offered by Jefferson Community College was celebrated at a recognition ceremony Friday at the Lewis County JCC Education Center.

Engineer Didn’t Prove That PLAs Save Money

By |April 24th, 2019|Categories: News, Statewide|

The PLA study, which cost Ogdensburg taxpayers $21,000, purports that with a series of false savings, labor consolidation and “management rights,” the project will save money. Yet no one challenged the study’s creator, Tim Seeler of Seeler Engineering, to positively prove those savings will be achieved. They also never asked him about the negative impact the lack of competition will have on the bidding process. They simply rubber-stamped the study and closed the door on local contractors and their employees.

Membership is available for general contractors, subcontractors, associates and suppliers.