Editorial — Too Hot to Handle: Labor Pact Didn’t Save Ogdensburg Any Money on Project Bids

From NNY360

City authorities estimated that the project to upgrade Ogdensburg’s wastewater treatment facility would cost $34,891,700.

Well, bids came in a tad higher than anticipated — the lowest one $6.2 million over budget, to be exact. In an email to the Watertown Daily Times, City Manager Sarah Purdy said that people involved with the project would analyze the bids to determine what can be done to lower expenses.

“Ogdensburg has no choice but to modernize its wastewater treatment plant and has been under state Department of Environmental Conservation order to do so for the past several years,” according to a story published Aug. 22 by the Watertown Daily Times. “The current plant can process 6.5 million gallons per day and services residential, commercial and industrial users within and adjacent to the Ogdensburg city limits. Constructed in 1965, the plant was partially updated most recently in 1978.”

City Councilors Timothy Davis and Daniel Skamperle prompted the council to consider whether using a PLA would be beneficial. Mayor Wayne L. Ashley said he also believed this may be worthwhile.

They argued that including a PLA would offer local firms the opportunity to bid on certain parts of the work. Without a PLA, the lowest bids could well come from out of state.

“It is common for large public works projects to be awarded to the lowest bidder, but adding a pre-existing labor agreement to a project is seen as a way to bolster union hiring while helping ensure that small companies have a chance to bid, according to proponents,” a May 17, 2018, Times story reported. “The PLAs can also set wage standards and other construction site requirements.”

A study proclaimed that Ogdensburg could save $900,000 with a PLA. So the City Council voted earlier this year to go this route.

As we’ve seen, the process didn’t go as officials had hoped.

Paul G. Carr, an adjunct associate professor of civil and environmental engineering at Cornell University, is an authority on construction costs and the bidding process. He is former chief executive officer of the Watertown engineering firm of Bernier Carr and Associates.

He told the Times that what lowers bids the most is wider competition. PLAs, however, limit companies that can bid on a project, he said. The result is higher bids when fewer firms compete.

“It’s not shocking, this is a pattern that we have seen with public works projects across New York state that are bid with project labor agreements,” Amanda Bertram, vice president of public affairs for the Associated Builders and Contractors/Empire State, said in a story published Saturday by the Times. “Across the board, they all come in millions of dollars over engineering estimates. This is a trend.”

Associated Builders and Contractors is a national trade organization representing those in the construction industry who don’t belong to unions. Ms. Bertram met with City Council members in November to discuss the disadvantages of using PLAs.

“Unions only account for 21 percent of the construction workforce across New York,” according to a news release issued Friday by the group. “Therefore, the PLA on this project effectively bars the majority of New York contractors — many of them local to Ogdensburg — and their workers from bidding and winning work that their own tax dollars fund.”

Officials need to re-examine if a PLA is the best option here. Judging from what bids have come in so far, our guess would be that it’s not.

Upcoming Events

Dec 02

Core Institute

December 2 @ 9:00 am - December 6 @ 5:30 pm
Dec 04

Hump Day Happy Hour

December 4 @ 5:00 pm - 7:00 pm
Dec 09

Core Institute

December 9 @ 9:00 am - December 13 @ 5:30 pm
Jan 07
Jan 08

As a full-service trade association, ABC offers a variety of information, tools and services to its members.

JOIN ABC

Marijuana Decriminalization to Pass, Wage Mandate Stalls

By |June 20th, 2019|Categories: News, Statewide, Uncategorized|

On Thursday, Cuomo declared a bill expanding a "prevailing wage" requirement that would apply to larger construction projects likely dead. The law would have expanded the definition of "public works" in New York to include projects receiving more than 30 percent of their funding from the government – making those projects eligible for the wage requirement. Powerful building trades unions, who are among Cuomo's most significant political supporters, had pushed the mandate this session.

Statement by Brian Sampson, President of the Associated Builders and Contractors Empire State Chapter Regarding Assemblyman Bronson’s New Prevailing Wage Bill (A.8418)

By |June 18th, 2019|Categories: ABC Press Release, News, Statewide|

The new Bronson prevailing wage bill is another sad attempt by the people we elect to do nothing more than appease the unions at the expense of the taxpayers.

Empire Chapter President, Brian Sampson Discusses The Devastating Impact of The New Prevailing Wage Bill

By |June 18th, 2019|Categories: ABC Press Release, News, Statewide|

As a full-service trade [...]

What’s Pushing Prevailing Wage Into The ‘Big Ugly’

By |June 11th, 2019|Categories: ABC Press Release, Statewide|

A lack of public hearings on the issue and the rush to get the bill passed by the end of session also means that final details of the bill will be determined behind closed doors, according to Brian Sampson, president of Empire Chapter of the Associated Builders and Contractors. “The potential impact of this bill, as drafted, could stop economic development in parts of this state for a long time,” he said. “Why aren't we talking about this bill more openly, and having more discussions and dialogue about it, instead of wrapping it up with a pretty little bow in the ‘Big Ugly?’”

Union Requirement Inflates Cost of State Fair Bridge

By |May 23rd, 2019|Categories: News, Statewide|

A shortage of bids on the New York State Fairgrounds pedestrian bridge project will leave New Yorkers paying more, but getting less. When plans for the project were released with an accompanying project labor agreement (PLA), the playing field narrowed from 20 companies interested in the project to just two submitting bids, with the lowest bid coming in well in excess of $1 million over engineering estimates. Why the drastic decrease in competition and increase in costs? The answer can be found in three simple letters: PLA.

Membership is available for general contractors, subcontractors, associates and suppliers.

JOIN ABC
2019-09-18T14:07:11-05:00