editorial as published in Crain’s NY Business Journal can be found here.
contractors can deliver cost-effective rental projects under the city's
tax-exemption program while paying middle-class wages.
Mayor Bill de Blasio is right to make affordable housing an integral
component of his policy agenda. His ambitious goal of creating 80,000
affordable housing units and preserving another 120,000 is laudable. But he
faces major obstacles, not the least of which is incentivizing developers to
build the units.
The mayor's plan would mandate that in new rental buildings, developers
appropriate 25% to 30% of apartments for lower-income residents in order to
receive a property-tax break from the city. That's a big ask, given the high
cost of construction in the city. But his motivational tool is a well-known tax
exemption called 421-a. The program, which provides a property-tax break for
new apartment projects citywide, along with requirement in certain high-priced
neighborhoods that 20% of units be affordable for low-income residents, is set
to expire June 15.
Conversations on the 421-a abatement program have run rampant at City Hall
and in Albany. Special interests have pushed hard to attach costly
prevailing-wage mandates to this incentive. We must understand that using
prevailing wage will result in fewer renovations as well as fewer new units.
The math is undeniable.
In all of these debates, there has been an insinuation that merit, or
nonunion, contractors pay poor wages. This could not be further from the truth.
They pay wages driven by market forces that allow employees to earn
middle-class incomes while still delivering cost-effective projects to
customers and taxpayers alike.
But nonunion contractors rarely bid prevailing-wage work because of another
misguided policy, annualization of wages and benefits, which exposes them to
arbitrary fines and penalties from the state Department of Labor.
Let's be clear: Prevailing wages are not average wages, as one might think.
In fact, according to the city comptroller's 2015 prevailing-wage schedule, a
carpenter would earn salary and benefits worth approximately $94 per hour,
while the average figure for a carpenter in the region is roughly $60. The
disparity is a major factor in why more construction is New York City is going
to merit-shop contractors.
In typical bureaucratic fashion, supporters of this convoluted wage proposal
seem to equate higher costs with better housing, failing to let the private
sector dictate best value for the best price. If developers' additional costs
to include affordable housing are to be mitigated through normal tax subsidies,
then these costs will ultimately be shouldered by the taxpayers of New York
City. Increased government involvement is simply not the answer.
Government should not be in the business of picking winners and losers, but
it will under this wage scheme. The winner? Organized labor, which is placed on
an uneven playing field on which others cannot compete. The losers? Renters who
need access to affordable housing, and taxpayers—both unfortunate casualties in
this attempt to have government interfere with the private market.
Click here to cancel reply.
Remember my details
Notify me of followup comments via e-mail
The National Labor Relations Board’s (NLRB) “Ambush Election” rule came into effect on April 14th, 2015 under President Obama. The rule effectively: ...
In the weeks after President Trump's tax reform bill passed, Governor Cuomo has become his own version of Paul Revere, but instead of the British, he's...
Re: As construction safety debate heats up, contracting group acknowledges shift away from unions
Well safety is a paramount thing to have around if any person is looking for and asking for safety an...
-- Write My Essay
Re: Associated Builders and Contractors Announces Seven-Figure Ad Buy
This post is very informative. The news and information provide in this article is very informative...
Re: "Union leaders demanding 'construction safety for all' should mean it"
Pretty helpful material, much thanks for this article
-- Online Law Homework Help
I’m really impressed with your article, such great & usefull knowledge you mentioned here
-- DissertationWriting Service
Good article for all of them lold
Good article for all of them
Associated Builders and Contractors announce very important ideas in this blog post. I know you are doing...
-- best essay writing service
Construction safety is one of the more critical issue that needs to be addressed. I believe that grademiners...
-- rushmyessay prices
Re: ABC Calls for Drug & Alcohol Testing on NYC Construction
I have bookmarked your website because this site contains valuable information in it. I am really happy...
-- Why Men Pull Away Review
Re: Bipartisan, ABC-supported Career and Technical Education Bill Introduced in Congress
I've read the book and really enjoyed Google it.
-- Harrison Horne